Review: Puddle Jumping by Amber L. Johnson
“Maybe what I needed was for this to be just a step up in the maturity. Both of the characters and the story, as well as the writing.”
~ Under the Covers
I’ve seen this book highly recommended around for years! I recently stumbled across it again and saw it was on KU so I decided to give it a try. Spur of the moment. I was interested to see a young adult contemporary that talked about a hero with autism.
I think overall there were things about this book that were good, but I don’t think the execution was what I wanted. The writing felt a little immature and that distracted me from the story. And I didn’t really care for our heroine much, which made it harder to connect with this story.
Then there’s Colton. While I liked his character, it was also very difficult to get to know him because there’s nothing from his POV. I think that would’ve added a great layer to this story and made it a deeper connection. I did really enjoy how Lilly had become so important for him basically his whole life, and how much she meant to him. But I wanted more.
Some things about this story, like I said, are interesting and kept me reading. I loved seeing the devotion of both Lilly and Colton’s family to making Colton as acclimated and normal as possible. And to ensure he felt loved. Maybe what I needed was for this to be just a step up in the maturity. Both of the characters and the story, as well as the writing.
![]()
What did you think of our review?
Let us know your thoughts in the comment box below!
![]()
![]()
[about-author author=”Amber L. Johnson”]
![]()
♡ Don’t want to miss any of our posts? ♡


I rarely read YA, thanks for the review.
Ty! For your review Francesca,too bad it wasn’t a better read!! Shared on my socials!??
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Francesca
I loved this novella. This is one of my favorites of all times. It’s been a little while since I’ve read it. Time for a reread! I think that the subject matter is very much written about lately. This novella was a head of the trend by a lot. I highly recommend Puddle Jumping.